Vol. 12 No. 2 (2015): Cultural Transitions in Ottoman Architecture
Articles

Brief notes on William James Smith’s architectural references to Greek revival at Taşkışla and Dolmabahçe Seyir Köşkü (Istanbul)

Turgut Saner
Department of Architecture, Faculty of Architecture, Istanbul Technical University, Istanbul, Turkey
Ertunç Denktaş
Architectural History Program, Graduate School of Science Engineering and Technology, Istanbul Technical University, Istanbul, Turkey
Gizem Mater
Department of Art History, Graduate School of Art and Social Sciences, Istanbul Technical University, Istanbul, Turkey
Figen Öztürk
Architectural History Program, Graduate School of Science Engineering and Technology, Istanbul Technical University, Istanbul, Turkey

Published 2015-07-01

Keywords

  • Greek revival,
  • William James Smith,
  • The portico of Taşkışla,
  • Dolmabahçe Seyir Köşkü,
  • The society of Dilettanti

How to Cite

Saner, T., Denktaş, E., Mater, G., & Öztürk, F. (2015). Brief notes on William James Smith’s architectural references to Greek revival at Taşkışla and Dolmabahçe Seyir Köşkü (Istanbul). A|Z ITU JOURNAL OF THE FACULTY OF ARCHITECTURE, 12(2), 83 - 91. Retrieved from https://www.az.itu.edu.tr/index.php/jfa/article/view/420

Abstract

As an architect of 19th century Neoclassicism, Smith designed two imperial buildings in Ottoman Istanbul, the portico of Taşkışla and Dolmabahçe Seyir Köşkü both displaying Greek revival references. The forms of the architectural elements of the Taşkışla portico can be considered within the conventions of the ancient Greek Ionic order as it was then known to the academics and designers. Obviously the publications of the Society of Dilettanti were highly influential among designer circles as intended by the members of the Society and also by the authors of the publications; so that they provided a starting point for Smith’s design as well. The formal features of the studied part of the Dolmabahçe Seyir Köşkü point out that the inspiration of the architect was based on the thesaurus of a group of ancient buildings depicted in Stuart and Revett’s 18th century publication on “Antiquities of Athens”. Smith manifestly repeated the column capitals of the Tower of the Winds in Athens at the Dolmabahçe design; in addition, the form of the Lesbian cymatium seen at the entablature of the pavilion is also most probably borrowed from the same publication. Further, at both designs it has been possible to show that Smith was inspired by certain Vitruvian and Palladian rules for proportions. The assumption prior to the research that Smith must have moved around the Vitruvian-Palladian systems with recognizable references to Greek revival architecture has been verified to a considerable extent.